TikTok being banned in the USA is not the issue

【Reporter Andys compiled the report】

TikTok being banned in the USA is not the issue. The fact is, this is a ban on any current or future successful technology owned by a potential adversary and, let’s not make any mistake about it, China, where the ownership of TikTok’s parent company sits, is considered to be the major adversary, for now and for no other reason than the fear that they may be.

Mud in the water is being stirred up because, the 「dreaded ccp」 could get its hands on the data collected by TikTok and who knows what they could do with that, probably the same as they do with the data they Can collect from our use of digitally connected fridges, cars, cranes, mobile phones, laptops, computers and anything else that’s connected, even though there’s no evidence anywhere that they might.

ByteDance has set up a separate company to comply with US laws, it houses all its data in the US, under US corporate supervision. It employes international, not Chinese, experts to run the company and the CEO, who has the 「misfortune」 to be of Chinese origin, has testified under oath that he is not affiliated with, nor has he ever been a member of the Communist Party, he’s testified under oath that he’s never been asked to provide information to the Communist Party of China and that, if asked, he would not comply.

Let’s be honest with ourselves, it isn’t about data protection, if it were, the US would need to completely isolate themselves from the rest of the world to protect their data, even Google and Meta, two of the largest 「data collection corporations」 in the world have not faced the same scrutiny. Meta was fined billions last year by the Irish government for a massive data breach because they transferred data to the US where Data Protection Laws are not strong enough.

In The Cambridge Analytica court case, where Facebook data was used to sway the results of an election, two senior engineers admitted, they don’t even know where Meta’s data is all stored.

Google is even more interesting, it has data storage centres all over the world including three in Asia, one of which is in Taiwan. They were also themselves charged but settled for almost half a billion dollars in the USA and fined in France for data protection breaches.

Bytedance received a fine over illegal medical advertising but as far as can be ascertained in this research has never been charged over data breaches.

Obviously, the issues with TikTok are not about data protection, there are already laws to protect data, Bytedance and TikTok have complied with them and have responded to every request by the US government to satisfy their insecurities.

What it is really about is far deeper than a national (in)security issue, it’s much more about a recognition, without any admission, that the very fabric of their society is in the process of being torn apart. The latest allegations to emerge prove this.

The same allegation has arisen in the UK too, China, through Douyin, the Chinese version, is apparently pushing teenagers toward educational and cultural content whereas TikTok, is directing the British and American youth towards addictive content designed to erode ambition and motivation.

The truth is, Douyin in China has similar content, it has bad dancing, lip-synching, make-up and other frivolous content and those videos are pushed out to people who enjoy watching them. But it also has a huge number of viewers interested in maths, space exploration, scientific experiments and they are promoted to viewers who enjoy watching them too.

It isn’t a stereotype to say that Chinese kids are more interested in these kinds of topics, take a look at any university program in the West and they will be filled with Asian kids getting Bachelor degrees, Masters and PhDs. Since long before TikTok and social media existed, Chinese kids were already filling those courses. The US Government told us this In 2007, China surpassed the United States as the world’s largest producer of natural sciences and engineering doctoral degrees. By 2020, the number from China and India had eclipsed the USA.

TikTok being banned in the USA is not the issue
TikTok being banned in the USA is not the issue

What has really taken place is not a Chinese plot to dumb down America, it’s a stated fact that the US is dumbing itself down, the National Centre for Educational Statistics reports there has been a decline in maths and reading as well as an increase in students seeking mental health services. While these problems have accelerated since the Covid Pandemic, they were identified well before. It seems TikTok’s algorithms are merely responding to the needs and desires of Americans in the same way they are responding to the needs and desires of Chinese viewers by providing them exactly what they want.

Putting education aside, the USA has found itself in what Queensland University of Technology Adjunct Professor Warwick Powell calls an Auto-immune deficiency, its own policies are eating away at the health of its society and systems. They want free speech; therefore, they don’t want legislation to protect their young people. They criticise China for 「censoring」 the internet but then criticise China’s social media for not allowing the dumbing down of its youth.

The USA has a generation addicted to social media but criticises China for limiting the time young people can spend on social media. Something MIT referred to as an 「Escalating war on kids screen time」.

What China has done is sensibly controlled and efficiently managed what kids can do online, what the US has done has created the conditions for the decline of its own society and would now like to blame the one country that’s done the opposite.

The US legislation to ban foreign ownership of social media will probably succeed and this is a bad thing. Bytedance (not the CPC) will need to make a decision. Sell, fight through the legal system, or close down and stop operating in the USA.

If Bytedance sells to a US corporation, it will not improve data security, it will not improve the quality of videos available to their young people, it will not turn around the decline in educational standards and it will not reduce social media addiction.

If Bytedance pulls out, their politicians will lose a lot more than the credibility that’s already bubbling down the drain; they will lose the votes of a great many young people. The US already has laws to protect data, it can create laws to improve what’s online and by doing so would reverse a worrying societal decline. That would however, meet intense resistance from US social media operators.

One must wonder whether the lawmakers themselves have been dumbed down to a point where common sense no longer prevails!


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here




【記者 劉夢緣 張如鳳 嘉義報導】 台灣國際職業婦女協會第12個分會成立大會,於3月23日晚上在嘉義市樂億皇家酒店舉行,由百合分會創會會長蔡佳靜主持,前副總統呂秀蓮、嘉義市長黃敏惠、立委王美惠、嘉義市社會處長黃晨毅、嘉義縣社會處局長張翠瑤及多位市議員等貴賓受邀與會,晚宴還有弱勢團體精彩表演。會中捐贈經費給啟智協會、北迴急難救助協會、世界和平展望會、創世基金會等團體,希望藉此拋磚引玉讓社會善士一起關懷弱勢團體。 台灣國際職業婦女協會百合分會創會長蔡佳靜表示,這次在嘉義創立第12個分會感謝大家的支持,尤其有40位優質企業女性一同為聯合國17+1項之任務為目標,提供職業婦女交流的合作平台並加強女性專業能力的國際觀,是婦女在各個領域都有專長的表現,落實女力新世代的價值。 前副總統呂秀蓮表示,遠在1973年,甫由美國留學回台兩年,孜孜矻矻於女權運動推展就已認知到與國際婦女組織接軌的重要性。呂前副總統說在她倡議之下,台灣國際職業婦女協會於2008年4月正式向國際職業婦女協會總會提出申請,並於2008年5月29日正式獲得總會認可,以台灣名義成立國家分會,成為世界國際職業婦女協會第82個國家分會。經過近十年的經營,歷經呂秀蓮創會理事長、尤美女名譽理事長、潘慧如名譽理事長、陳双喜名譽理事長與現任郭壽珍理事長的優質領導,該會儼然已成為台灣重要的婦女組織之一。 黃敏惠市長表示,嘉義市是民主聖地,不分藍綠但有是非,這也是呂副總統長期以來令人尊重的地方,總是講真話、為社會美好在努力;今天成立台灣國際職業婦女協會第12個分會,是個國際組織,藉由這樣的機會,希望能夠讓台灣婦女的表現被全世界看到,也歡迎大家來幸福城市嘉義市。

台灣國際職業婦女協會理事長改選 郭壽珍榮任第八屆理事長

【記者 劉夢緣 張如鳳 台中報導】 台灣國際職業婦女協會(簡稱BPW)為一國際性的女性社團組織,目前全世界的會員國一共有100多個,是比聯合國更早成立的國際性婦女組織。 台灣是在2008年成為國際職業婦女協會(簡稱IFBPW)的會員國。目前台灣共有11個分會,每2年由11個分會推派代表,透過選舉產生總會理事長。今年適逢理事長更迭,乃於12月24日星期六下午,假臺中市北屯區的葳格國際會議中心舉行第八屆總會理事長選舉。選舉結果,由大臺中分會推派的郭壽珍代表勝出,出任第八屆總會理長。 新上任的郭壽珍理事長本身從事環保綠建材的營銷,另同時兼營雷射切割工程。郭理事長因長期接觸綠建材,深知永續經營及友善環境的重要性,積極涉略企業零碳排、碳權交易的議題。為了能在該領域有更高遠的前瞻性,乃報考進入勤益科技大學的產業碩士班就讀。 每位新任理事長皆有新願景及執行計畫。對郭壽珍理事長而言,首要任務為執行聯合國永續經營的17項指標,這也是協會追求的宗旨。其次為積極推動碳匯、碳權及公元2050年淨零碳排的目標。另外女力的提昇與培訓亦為會務發展的重點。 在性別平等方面,加強女性專業能力及國際觀,婦女在各領域都能發展長才,婦女對國家發展與國際事務之關心,保護婦女權益。未來執行計劃,推展為團隊定義共同目標,SDGS、ESG科技、農業、氣候變遷、人權各方面女性都可以盡一分心力。 郭壽珍理事長談到未來的會務與願景:「因為愛責任在,實踐價值所以堅持。」。最後,郭理事長希望攜手全國600多位會姐的力量,利用兩年的任期,做好多項指標性的任務,讓全世界看到台灣女力的亮點。


【記者 劉夢緣 張如鳳 台中報導】 國際傑人會世界總會11月18日在台中寶麗金會館,舉行2024年總會長連任暨理事宣誓就職典禮。由2023年現任世界總會長吳毓苹連任2024年總會長。 吳毓苹畢業於靜宜大學化學系,是靜宜大學第二屆傑出校友,同時也是世界台灣同鄉聯誼總會永久名譽總會長、世界華商經貿聯合總會名譽總會長,長年旅居美國舊金山灣區,曾任僑務委員及僑務諮詢委員。 連任典禮邀請1997年總會長黃書瑋,也是現任台北龍山寺董事長監交。並舉行2024年理事及組織八處處長宣誓就職,2024年世界總會副總會長有賴文針(新任)、林瑞楨(新任)、吳睦野(新任)、蔡宗旻(連任)、林文發(連任)、吳三瑋(連任)、蔡明展(連任)、魏德珍(新任)、梁華(新任)、游明桂(新任)、謝雷(新任)、胡淑文(新任)、劉宏洲(新任)等13位。2024年組織八處包括秘書處劉天倫秘書長、王清耀、寇惠風、劉年富3位副秘書長,饒心怡秘書,財務處財務長郭阿月    、副財務長黃淡水,會務發展處處長蘇淑榕,公共關係處處長林秀烜,法規規章處處長呂文三,基金管理處處長廖秋月,會籍管理處處長周麗秋,研究發展處處長蔡志強,法制顧問吳文虎,文化顧問陳在棟,資訊組組長莊岳霖,文宣組組長陳佳娜。當天觀禮貴賓包括靜宜大學校長林思伶、校友服務中心執行長汪凱彰,世界前總會長們包括黃書瑋、柯雨財、林柏根、張正章、葉論飛、陳國書、傅忠雄,阿根廷代表李茂勇,非洲代表明翠中,美國洛杉磯代表楊綺真,美國北加州代表吳明政,香港總會代表梁華總會長、何楓群,吳總會長大學同學劉秀齡博士及來自世界各地會員代表及來賓共襄盛舉! 靜宜大學校長林思伶致詞時表示:「今天是第二次參加傑人會交接典禮,感覺非常親切,傑人會是注重道德品格的社團,如同是國際社會大學,與一般大學培養道德品德是一樣的。」 監交人黃書瑋致詞表示:「傑人會於民國    57年創立,目前發展到國際各地,吳毓苹總會長於任副總會長期間輔導成立9個分會,現在當總會長任內已成立6個分會,值得讚許。」 吳毓苹致詞表示:「國外創會非常辛苦,要花費相當多的人力、物力、時間,常是頂著鋼盔向前衝,目前國際傑人會世界總會全球共有70個分會;2023年接任世界總會長,上任世界總會長以來,今年四月份成立美國芝加哥和平分會及西雅圖分會,七月份成立英國倫敦分會及荷蘭海牙分會,八月份成立澳洲維多利亞分會,十月份在中華民國總會的努力下成立了嘉義分會,希望在2024年任內完成80個分會。」 吳毓苹有鑑於國際傑人會是根據中華文化的四維八德為基礎,以服務社會、助人邁向傑出為任務,促進社會大同為終極目標。全球各大都會的華裔人才眾多,可以吸收為國際傑人會的生力軍,未來再借重華裔推廣至世界各族裔。在這ㄧ方面仍有待努力開發。吳毓苹指出:2024年仍延續「傑人文化、榮耀傳承;改革創新、發揚光大」之年度主題,繼續加強發揚。